7 min read

Gameweek 10: Gabriel or Haaland as Captain

We expect 6.16 points from Gabriel against Hull City and 4.71 from Haaland at Forest. How each side scores and concedes, and what would change that.

The deadline is 18:30 in London on Friday 6 November, ninety minutes before Everton play Coventry City.

Haaland is owned by 79.1% of managers and Gabriel by 25.3%. We expect 6.16 points from Gabriel against Hull City and 4.71 from Haaland at Nott'm Forest. If you own both, we would give Gabriel the captaincy.

Three terms need a word first. Expected goals is what a team's chances are worth, so 2.00 means two goals of chances created, not two goals scored. Set pieces means corners, free kicks and throw-ins, with penalties counted apart. The middle of the penalty area means the width of the six-yard box, from the goal line to the edge of the area.

The two numbers, line by line

LineGabrielHaaland
Appearance1.921.83
Clean sheet2.200.00
Goals conceded-0.100.00
Defensive contribution0.660.00
Goals0.981.64
Penalties0.000.30
Assists0.240.39
Bonus0.380.62
Cards-0.12-0.07
xPTS6.164.71
Doubled12.329.42

Playing and defending give Gabriel 4.68 of his 6.16 points. We give him a 55% chance of a clean sheet, which alone takes him to 6 points, or 12 as captain.

Haaland takes 2.33 of his 4.71 points from goals, penalties and assists. We expect 0.49 goals from him, about a 38% chance of scoring at least once. With no goal and no assist he scores 2 points, or 4 as captain.

Gabriel's 6.16 points are the highest number on the board this week. Haaland's 4.71 are 14th.

Haaland at Nott'm Forest

Saturday 17:30, City Ground. City are 56% to win, the draw is 23% and Forest are 21%. We expect City to create 2.03 goals of chances against 1.20, and we give them a 30% chance of a clean sheet against Forest's 13%.

City have created 17.94 expected goals in nine league games, the most in the league. Forest have allowed 9.72, and only Arsenal have allowed less. Our 2.03 is tied to the betting market and sits above the record: City have created 1.41 a game away, and Forest have allowed 0.95 a game at home.

Of that 2.03, we expect 0.49 goals and 0.13 assists from Haaland, a goal or an assist in 30% of City's expected goals. We give him a 92% chance of starting, after he played 90 minutes in Leipzig on Wednesday.

All 9 of Haaland's goals came from the middle of the penalty area, with 5.61 of his 5.97 expected goals. Forest have allowed 7.40 there, the seventh lowest in the league.

Type of chanceHaaland xGHaaland goalsForest allowed xGLeague average xG
Middle of the area5.6197.409.13
Headers in open play0.6930.421.02
Set pieces1.1713.083.14
Corners0.3401.961.73

Four of Haaland's 9 goals are headers and 3 of those came in open play. Forest have allowed 0.42 expected goals from headers in open play, the sixth lowest in the league.

Forest's weak point is the corner. They have allowed 1.67 expected goals from headers at corners, the fifth most in the league. Oliver Glasner, Forest's manager, said this on Thursday about the 2-0 defeat at Brentford: "they had seven touches in our box and I think four came from set pieces" (press conference). Haaland has taken 4 of City's 28 shots from corners, worth 0.34 of their 2.55 expected goals from corners, and has not scored from one.

City are without Antoine Semenyo, who has a knee injury. Glasner said Daniel Muñoz had "some minor issues with his foot, but looks okay. Trained the week" (press conference).

Gabriel against Hull City

Saturday 15:00, Emirates Stadium. Arsenal are 83% to win, the draw is 13% and Hull are 5%. We expect Arsenal to create 2.76 goals of chances against 0.55, and we give them a 58% chance of a clean sheet against Hull's 6%.

Hull have created 9.03 expected goals, the second lowest in the league, and have scored 11. Sergej Jakirović, their manager, said on Thursday that Hull have to "try to use some moments when we win the ball or some counter-attacks, and also to be very, very responsible in set-pieces" (press conference).

Type of chanceHull goalsHull xGArsenal concededArsenal allowed xG
Set pieces42.5621.84
Counter-attacks21.3910.71
Other open play44.3023.70
Penalties10.7900.79
Total119.0357.04

Set pieces are 4 of Hull's 11 goals, or 36%, against 20% across the league. Two of the four came in one game, against Manchester United in gameweek 1.

Arsenal have allowed 1.84 expected goals from set pieces in nine games, the third lowest in the league. Two of the 5 goals they have conceded came from set pieces, so the risk is real and small: 0.20 expected goals a game.

Hull allow few chances from set pieces: 2.31 expected goals, the sixth lowest in the league, and one goal. They do allow headers: 3.68 expected goals, the second most in the league. Four of Gabriel's 9 shots are headers, worth 0.84 of his 1.38 expected goals, and his one goal, against Everton in gameweek 8, was a header. We expect 0.16 goals and 0.08 assists from him, which is 1.22 of his 6.16 points.

Mikel Arteta said on Friday that Bukayo Saka is "going to be out for a while" (press conference via Beanyman Sports). Ezri Konsa had a knee problem, and Arteta said: "Yeah, he's fine. He was feeling much better today" (press conference via Beanyman Sports). Gabriel has played all 810 league minutes and the full 90 in Prague on Wednesday, and we give him a 97% chance of starting.

What would change the call

Our projection gives Haaland 24% of City's expected goals and Gabriel 6% of Arsenal's. This season Haaland has 33.3% of City's expected goals and 45% of their goals, and Gabriel has 9.3% of Arsenal's expected goals and 7.1% of their goals.

ReadingHaaland goalsHaaland xPTSGabriel goalsGabriel xPTS
Our projection0.494.710.166.16
At his share of expected goals0.685.470.266.72
At his share of goals0.916.430.206.36

These add 4 points per goal for Haaland and 6 for Gabriel and change nothing else.

Haaland only passes Gabriel in the last row, which needs him to keep scoring 9 goals from 5.97 expected goals. We tested paying players for past finishing in our projections and it made them worse at every strength we tried.

From gameweek 4 to gameweek 9 we expected 35.31 points from Haaland at the deadlines and he scored 44. We expected 28.22 from Gabriel and he scored 43.

If you do not own Gabriel

Three managers in four do not own him.

PlayerGamePrice €OwnedxPTSDoubled
TzolisArsenal v Hull City6.13.9%5.7511.50
B.FernandesMan Utd v Aston Villa11.721.0%5.4210.84
CalafioriArsenal v Hull City5.948.4%5.3010.60
HaalandNott'm Forest v Man City15.879.1%4.719.42

Riccardo Calafiori is the one most managers can use: 48.4% own him, and doubled he is 10.60 points against Haaland's 9.42.

Haaland has scored 13 points twice this season. If he does it again and you own him without the captaincy, you lose 13 points to every manager who captained him.

Where these numbers come from

The club numbers come from a goal model built on the quality of the chances each team creates and allows, then adjusted to the betting market. The player numbers are built from those, line by line, under the Premier League's scoring rules.

The types of chance are counted from every shot in the 90 league games played so far, and those counts do not go into xPTS: the model reads how much a club creates and allows, and not how. Our shot count gives Haaland 5.97 expected goals and the game's own figure is 6.56, so a number here can differ a little from the one on his page.

We read the projections at 14:37 in London on 6 November.

Two honest limits. Nine games is a small sample for any of these splits. And team sheets arrive after the deadline, so both start chances are our estimate.

Read next

6 min read

The Defender Board

What the model expects from every Premier League defender this season, and what you pay for it. Gabriel is projected to score the most points and to be the worst value on the board.

17 min read

Gameweek 3: Where the Points Are

Seven games, and the cheapest good ones are at the bottom of the table. Who to pick in each, and the popular names our numbers do not back.